Design and Analysis of Optimal Ecological Flow Regime Zarrin-Gol River Using Hydrological Methods and Ecohydraulic Habitat Simulation Model

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

• Mohammad Hasan Naderi ¹
• M. Zakerinia ²
• Meysam Salarijazi ³

¹ M.Sc. of Water Resources Engineering and Ecohydraulic Researcher of River Habitats, Water Engineering Department, Faculty of Water and Soil Engineering, Gorgan University of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, Gorgan, Iran

² Gorgan

³ Department of Water Engineering Water & Soil Engineering Faculty Gorgan University of Agricultural S

10.22067/jsw.v34i3.79294

Abstract

Introduction: The field of ecohydraulics is rapidly growing as the society requires a better understanding of the interrelations amongst the dynamics of the physical processes pertaining to aquatic ecosystems and the modifications observed in their habitat as well as the biological responses of the organisms. Environmental flow science is a common tool for assessing the consequences of changing the flow regime of aquatic ecosystems and providing a minimum flow of aquatic species protection. Environmental Flows assessment is a global challenge involving a number of tangible and intangible segments of hydrology, hydraulics, biology, ecology, environment, socio-economics, and several other branches of engineering including water resources management. River impoundment (dams, weirs), water diversions and consequent modifications to flow regimes have highly destructive effects on aquatic species and ecosystems.    
Materials and Methods: In this research, two most common hydrologic methods Tennant and FDC Shifting were compared with a habitat simulation method i.e. PHABSIM. Tennant method is the most popular hydrological method in rivers and is based on the historic flow data. Investigation of the relationship between hydrologic approaches and physical habitat simulation approach and presentation of new recommendations based on the ecological and hydrological data can be very useful for estimating environmental flow in planning phase of river projects. We used river habitat simulation program to model the depth and velocities around boulder clusters to evaluate the habitat for Capoeta habitat in Zarrin-Gol River. The Zarrin-Gol River is one of the rivers in Golestan province in northern Iran. The statistics required for hydrologic calculations were also collected from Zarrin-Gol hydrometry station during the 42-year statistical period (1353-1395). In this regard, after the field studies and the development of the habitat suitability model for the target species, the Habitat simulation of the flow was carried out and eventually the ecological flow regime was extracted. In order to identify the important habitat variables and assess their impact, the life pattern of fish species was divided into juvenile and adult life stages.
Results and Discussion: Based on ecological assessment, the environmental water requirement of Gharahsoo river is 30% of mean annual flow for spring and summer and 10% of mean annual flow for autumn and winter seasons. It was found that application of Tennant and FDC Shifting methods led to dramatically low discharges as fixed minimum environmental flows, while habitat simulation method gave an acceptable estimation of ecological regime. However, habitat simulation technique assesses the allowable value of extraction from river flow dynamically, considering the ecological condition and average intermediate values. River conditions including flow velocity, water depth and river bed substrate are combined to form unique habitats facilitating the survival and growth of fish species populations.  Habitat forms are observed in a wide range of rivers depending on the diet and the river type such as Pool, Riffle and Run. The destruction of the Riffle substrate causes disruption and impacts the biological integrity of the current. According to the Q-WUA curve of the Riffle habitat in high waters and flood conditions, the area available for juveniles of the target species decreases because of the flood, morphology and habitat of the river, so large and continuous floods inhibit the opportunity to rebuild habitats from the river and endanger the lives of fish. One of the factors limiting the desirability of the habitat and thus reducing the available habitat in low river flows is the low flow velocity, as well as high stream flow flows. The maximum and minimum flow regime, required to maintain the Zarrin-Gol river ecosystem according to ecological needs, was 2.49 and 0.58 m3/s in April and November, respectively, with an average value of 1.25 m3/s (59 % of natural stream of the river). In the next step, habitat suitability distribution along the stream was investigated. This was performed for the full range of discharges. Habitat suitability distribution along the stream at different discharges indicated that the upstream part of the stream had the poorest habitat condition and moving towards the downstream parts, the habitat suitability condition was improved.
Conclusion: Application of the Tennant method based on a hydrological system can be an inappropriate choice for determining the minimum flow to maintain the ecological environment of the river. According to the results, the PHABSIM model can simulate flow, habitat suitability of target species and the habitats dynamics accurately, which is highly required to protect the proper habitat of fish in river ecosystems.

Keywords

• Environmental Flow
• Habitat simulation
• Hydrological methods
• Zarrin-Gol river

---

References

1- Abdoli A., and Naderi M. 2009. Biodiversity of Fishes of the Southern Basin of the Caspian Sea. Abzian Scientific Publication. (In Persian)

2- Ahmadzadeh M., Poorbagher H., and Eagderi S. 2018. Calculating the habitat suitability index of Siahmahi (Capoeta buhsei, Kessler 1877) using the kernel smoothing in the Jajrood River, Namak basin of Iran. Journal of Aquaculture Sciences 6(9): 99-108. (In Persian with English abstract)

3- Armas-Vargas F., Escolero O., Garcia de Jalon D., Zambrano L., Gonzalez del Tanago M., and Kralisch S. 2017. Proponiendo el caudal ambiental basado en simulacion del habitat fisico para cinco especies de peces en la Cuenca baja del Rio Duero, Mexico. Hidrobiologica 27(2): 185-200.

4- Arthington A.H., Kennen J.G., Stein E.D., and Webb J.A. 2018. Recent advances in environmental flows science and water management—Innovation in the Anthropocene. Freshwater Biology 1-13.

5- Asadi H., Sattari M., and Eagdari S. 2014. Investigation of the determinants of selectivity and preferential habitat Capoeta capoeta gracilis (Keyserling 1891) in the Siahrood River. Iranian Journal of Fisheries Science 23(3): 1-9. (In Persian)

6- Ayyoubzadeh S.A., Sedighkia M., and Hajiesmaeili M. 2018. Ecohydraulics and Simulation of River Habitats.Water Engineering Research Institude Tarbiat Modares University. (In Persian)

7- Azarang F., Telvari A.R., Sedghi H., and Shafaei Bajestan M. 2017. Large Dam Effects on Flow Regime and Hydraulic Parameters of river (Case study: Karkheh River, Downstream of Reservoir Dam). Journal of Water and Soil 31(1): 11-27 (In Persian with English abstract)

8- Bourgeois G., Cunjak R.A., Caissie D., and El-Jabi N. 1996. A spatial and temporal evaluation of PHABSIM in relation to measured density of juvenile Atlantic salmon in a small stream. North American Journal of Fisheries Management 16(1): 154-166.

9- Brown J.H., Stevens G.C., and Kaufman D.M. 1996. The geographic range: size, shape, boundaries, and internal structure. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 27(1): 597-623.

10- Esmaili K., Sadeghe Z., Kaboli A., and Shafaei H. 2018. Application Hydrological methods for estimating River Environmental water rights (Case Study of Gorganroud River). Journal of Natural Environmenatal (Iranian Journal of Natural Recorces) 71(4): 437-451. (In Persian with English abstract)

11- Gholizadeh M., Toomaj A., and Hossiendost S. 2017. Modeling habitat requirements of riverine stone loach, Paracobitis hircanica (Teleostei: Nemacheilidae) in the Zarin-Gol River, Caspian Sea basin, Iran. Iranian Journal of Ichthyology 4(4): 340-351.

12- Gholizadeh M., Patimar R., and Harsij M. 2018. Investigation of Selected Habitat Range of the Paracobitis hicanica in the Zarin-Gol River, Golestan Province. Journal of Applied Ichthyological Research 6(2): 1-12. (In Persian)

13- Kim J.S., Lee C.J., Kim W., and Kim Y.J. 2010. Roughness coefficient and its uncertainty in gravel-bed river. Water Science and Engineering 3(2): 217-232.

14- Mostafavi S., and Yasi M. 2015. Evaluation of Environmental Flows in Rivers Using Hydrological Methods (Case study: The Barandozchi River- Urmia Lake Basin). Journal of Water and Soil 29(5): 1219-1231. (In Persian with English abstract)

15- Naderi M.H., Zakerinia M., and Salarizji M. 2018. Application of the PHABSIM model in Explaining the Ecological Regime of the River in order to Estimate the Environmental Flow and Compare with Hydrological Methods (Case Study: Gharasoo River). Ecohydrology 5(3): 941-955. (In Persian)

16- Naderi M.H, Zakerinia M., and Salarijazi M. 2019. Investigation of Ecohydraulic Indices in Environmental Flow Regime and Habitat Suitability Simulation Analysis using River2D Model with Relying on the Restoration Ecological in Zarrin-Gol River. Journal of Ecohydrology 6(1): 205-222. (In Persian)

17- Naderi M.H, Pourgholam-Amiji M., Ahmadaali K., Amiri Z., Ghojoghi A., and Ghorbani Minaei L. 2020. Determining the Range of Optimal Environmental Flow in Zarin-Gol River through Hydromorphological Characteristics, Hydrological Regime and Habitat Suitability Simulation Ecohydraulic Model. Journal of Fisheries (Iranian Journal of Natural Recources) 71(3): 317-328. (In Persian with English abstract)

18- Najafabadi E.F., Afzalimehr H., and Rowinski P.M. 2018. Flow structure through a fluvial pool-riffle sequence–Case study. Journal of Hydro-environment Research 19:1-15.

19- Nakvachara P., Rittima A., and Talaluxmana Y. 2018. Quantification of Environmental Flow Requirement of Khun Dan Prakan Chon Dam Using Hydrological-hydraulic-ecological Methods. Applied Environmental Research 40(2): 76-90.

20- Nikghalb S., Shokoohi A., Singh V.P, and Yu R. 2016.Ecological regime versus minimum environmental flow: comparison of results for a river in a semi Mediterranean region. Water Resources Management 30(13): 4969-84.

21- Olsen N. 2012. Numerical Modelling & Hydraulics, 3rd Edition, Department of Environmental Engineering: The Norwegian University of Science & Technology.

22- Sedighkia M., Ayyoubzadeh S.A., and Hajiesmaeli M. 2017. Modification of Tennant and Wetted Perimeter Methods in Simindasht Basin, Tehran Province. Civil Engineering Infrastructures Journal 50(2): 221-31.

23- Sedighkia M., Abdoli A., Ayyoubzadeh S.A., Ahmadi A.A., and Gholizadeh M. 2017. Development of the native method of environmental flow in the rivers of the southern basin of Kaspian-Lar National Park. Journal of Ecology 43(3): 543-560. (In Persian)

24- Shamekhi K., Patimar R., Ghorbani R., and Kordjazi Z. 2012. Comparison relative of abundance of Capoeta capoeta gracilis in five streams of Gorganroud River Basin, Golestan Province, Northern Iran. Journal of Research in Biology 1: 19-22.

25- Smakhtin V.U., and Anpurhas M. 2006. An assessment of environmental flow requirements of Indian river basins. IWMI Research Report 107. International Water Management Institute, Colombo, Sri Lanka.

26- Tennant D.L. 1976. Instream flow regimens for fish, wildlife, recreation and related environmental resources. Fisheries 1(4): 6-10.

27- Wang H., Wang H., Hao Z., Wang X., Liu M., and Wang Y. 2018. Multi-Objective Assessment of the Ecological Flow Requirement in the Upper Yangtze National Nature Reserve in China Using PHABSIM. Water 10(3): 1-16.

28- Yi Y., Cheng X., Yang Z., Wieprecht S., Zhang S., and Wu Y. 2017. Evaluating the ecological influence of hydraulic projects: A review of aquatic habitat suitability models. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 68: 748-762.

29- Zarakani M., Shookohi A., and Pising V. 2017. Introducing a comprehensive ecological diet in the absence of data to determine the true environmental status of rivers. Iranian Water Resources Research Journal 13(2): 140-153. (In Persian with English abstract)

30- Zhao C.S., Yang S.T., Zhang H.T., Liu C.M., Sun Y., Yang Z.Y., Zhang Y., Dong B.E., and Lim R.P. 2017. Coupling habitat suitability and ecosystem health with AEHRA to estimate E-flows under intensive human activities. Journal of Hydrology 551: 470-483.